Introduction

Sales commissions can seem confusing, but they're super important for any kind of business. Whether you have a small shop or a growing tech company, understanding commissions can really help you succeed. In this guide, we'll go over the different ways you can set up commissions, how to handle the accounting side of things, and what this all means for your taxes. Ready to make sense of it all? Let's get started!

1. Sales Commission Models

Straight Salary

In a Straight Salary model, employees receive a fixed, predictable salary regardless of sales made. This approach is best suited for roles where sales aren't the primary focus.

When to Use: Best suited for businesses where sales are a small part of a broader job role. For example, in retail or client service roles where the focus is on customer satisfaction, not just sales figures.

Example: Sarah works as a customer service rep and earns $40,000 a year. Whether she upsells additional features to a customer or not, her salary remains the same.

Salary Plus Commission

Employees get the best of both worlds: a guaranteed salary plus extra earnings from commissions. This is a solid choice if you need steady sales but also want to incentivize performance.

When to Use: Ideal for businesses that require consistent performance and have a relatively short, straightforward sales cycle. This model provides security with a salary and an additional performance incentive through commissions.

Example: Mike has a base salary of $30,000 but also earns a 5% commission on each sale. If he closes a $2,000 deal, he earns an additional $100.

ItemAmountDetailsBase Salary$30,000Fixed annual incomeCommission Rate5%Percentage of each sale that Mike earns as commissionDeal Closed$2,000Value of the deal Mike closesCommission Earned on Deal$1005% of $2,000Total Earnings from Deal$100Commission earned from this particular dealAnnual Salary with Commission$30,100Base Salary + Commission earned from this deal

Straight Commission

Pay is entirely performance-based, linked to the sales or profits an employee generates. Be aware, this high-risk, high-reward setup could result in a revolving door of staff if not managed well.

When to Use: Suited for highly competitive industries where high performance directly impacts company success. This model is common in sectors like real estate and high-value B2B sales, where individual deals can bring significant revenue.

Example: Emily gets no salary but earns 10% commission on her total sales. If she sells $8,000 worth of products in a month, she takes home $800.

ItemAmountDetailsBase Salary$0Emily has no fixed annual incomeCommission Rate10%Percentage of total sales that Emily earns as commissionTotal Sales in a Month$8,000Value of all products Emily sells in a monthCommission Earned in a Month$80010% of $8,000Total Earnings in a Month$800Commission earned in this particular month

Draw Against Commission

Employees receive a 'draw'—essentially a paycheck advance—to cover living costs, which they later 'pay back' through earned commissions. Keep a close eye on the books; this model needs meticulous accounting.

When to Use: Useful for businesses that have a fluctuating sales cycle. The 'draw' provides a safety net during lean periods, incentivizing the employee to make up for it during peak sales times. This model is commonly seen in seasonal businesses.

Example: Jack receives a $2,000 draw at the beginning of the month. He must earn this back in commissions. If he makes $3,000 in commissions, he would take home $1,000 extra after paying back the draw.

ItemAmountDetailsDraw Amount$2,000Initial amount given to Jack at the beginning of the monthCommission Earned$3,000Total commissions Jack earns during the monthDraw Repaid$2,000The initial draw amount that needs to be "repaid"Additional Earnings After Draw$1,000Remaining commission after repaying the draw ($3,000 - $2,000)Total Take-home for the Month$1,000Total income Jack gets to keep after repaying the draw

In Jack's case, he initially receives a $2,000 draw against his future commissions. Over the course of the month, he earns $3,000 in commissions. To determine his take-home pay for the month, he must first "repay" the $2,000 draw. The remaining $1,000 is what he gets to keep as his additional earnings for that month.

Tiered Commission

Commissions increase as employees hit specific revenue milestones. A great way to push your team to excel and aim for higher sales goals.

When to Use: Great for businesses that want to push their sales team to reach higher quotas or achieve 'stretch' goals. Once an employee reaches a certain level of sales, their commission rate increases, providing an incentive for exceptional performance.

Example: Lisa earns a 5% commission on her first $5,000 of sales. Any sales beyond that, she earns a 7% commission. So if she makes $7,000 in sales, she earns $250 from the first $5,000 and $140 from the remaining $2,000.

ItemSales AmountCommission RateCommission EarnedDetailsFirst Tier Sales$5,0005%$250Commission earned on first $5,000 of sales (5% of $5,000)Second Tier Sales$2,0007%$140Commission earned on sales beyond $5,000 (7% of $2,000)Total Sales$7,000N/AN/ATotal sales amount for the monthTotal Commission EarnedN/AN/A$390Total commission earned for the month ($250 from first tier + $140 from second tier)

In Lisa's case, her commission rate changes based on her total sales for the month. She earns a 5% commission on her first $5,000 in sales, which amounts to $250. For sales beyond that initial $5,000, her commission rate increases to 7%. With an additional $2,000 in sales, she earns an extra $140. In total, Lisa would earn $390 in commissions for the month based on $7,000 in sales.

Each of these structures comes with its own set of advantages and challenges, so you'll need to consider what aligns best with your business goals, sales team dynamics, and the financial stability of your organization.

2. Types of Sales Commissions

Revenue Commission

Commission is calculated as a percentage of the total sales revenue. It's straightforward but ignores the cost of goods or services sold.

Example: Megan earns a 10% commission on a software package she sells for $1,000. She takes home $100, regardless of the cost it took to produce the software.

Gross Margin Commission

This considers the profit made from a sale, taking into account both revenue and costs.

Example: Tony sells a product for $1,000 with a production cost of $200. His commission is 20% of the $800 profit, so he earns $160.

Volume-Based Commission

The rate of commission increases with the volume of units sold. This can encourage bulk sales, but there's the risk of sacrificing quality.

Example: If Sophia sells up to 10 units, she gets a 5% commission. For 11-20 units, it's 7%. She sells 15 units and earns 7% commission per unit.

Team-Based Commission

The commission is calculated based on the team's collective performance, not individual achievement.

Example: Team Alpha hits a sales target of $50,000, and each team member earns a share of a $5,000 bonus, regardless of individual contributions.

Special Incentives and Bonuses

These are one-off financial rewards for hitting milestones or completing special projects.

Example: Emma closes a deal with a high-profile client and receives a one-time $500 bonus, on top of her regular commission.

3. Accounting Journal Entries for Sales Commissions

Accrual Method

In the accrual method of accounting, commissions are recorded as an expense when they are earned, regardless of when they are paid. This also creates a liability on the balance sheet, representing the amount that is owed to the salesperson but has not yet been paid.

Example: If your salesperson, Clara, closes a $10,000 deal in March and earns a 10% commission, you would record a $1,000 commission expense and a $1,000 liability in March—even if you don't pay Clara until April. This method gives a more accurate snapshot of your company’s financial position for March.

Accounting Journal Entries for Clara's Sales Commissions in March:

DateAccount TitleDebit ($)Credit ($)NotesMarch 31Commission Expense1,000To record the commission expense Clara earned on the $10,000 saleMarch 31Commission Payable1,000To record the liability for commission to be paid to Clara

Cash Method

Under the cash method of accounting, commissions are only recorded when they are actually paid out to the salesperson. This method is simpler than the accrual method but might not provide a complete picture of your pending financial obligations.

Example: If Jane closes a $20,000 deal in February and you pay her a 5% commission in March, the $1,000 commission expense is only recorded in March when she receives the payment. So, your financial records for February won't show this pending expense.

Accounting Journal Entries for Jane's Sales Commissions in March (Cash Basis):

DateAccount TitleDebit ($)Credit ($)NotesMarch 1Commission Expense1,000To record the commission expense for Jane's $20,000 sale in FebruaryMarch 1Cash1,000To record the payment of the commission to Jane

Commissions in Payroll

When you pay commissions as part of the regular payroll, it means that the sales bonuses are included in your employees' regular paychecks. This way, you're dealing with one less separate payment, making life a bit easier for you and your bookkeeper.

Example: Let's say Sarah has a base salary of $3,000 per month and earned $500 in commissions. When payroll time comes, she receives a single paycheck for $3,500. On your end, both her salary and commission would be processed at the same time, making it easier to manage.

Accounting Journal Entries for Sarah's Salary and Commissions (Payroll Time):

DateAccount TitleDebit ($)Credit ($)NotesPayroll DateSalary Expense3,000To record Sarah's base salary for the monthPayroll DateCommission Expense500To record Sarah's earned commissionPayroll DateCash or Bank3,500To record the payment of salary and commission to Sarah

Special Cases

Special cases can involve anything from advances against commissions to recoverable draws. These situations demand specific accounting entries to accurately reflect the financial arrangement.

Example 1 - Advances Against Commissions:

Let's say you pay Sally a $2,000 advance against future commissions. In your books, this creates a $2,000 liability under "Advance Against Commissions" that is gradually reduced as Sally earns her commissions.

Step 1: Initial Accounting for Advance Against Commissions to Sally

DateAccount TitleDebit ($)Credit ($)NotesAdvance DateAdvance Against Commissions2,000To record the advance paid to SallyAdvance DateCash or Bank2,000To record the payment of advance against commissions to Sally

To settle the advance against commissions for Sally, you would need to make accounting entries that reduce the "Advance Against Commissions" liability account as she earns her commissions. The entries would reflect the commission Sally has earned, thereby reducing the advance amount. Once Sally earns enough in commissions to "pay off" the advance, the liability is cleared.

Step 2: Accounting for Earnings and Settling Advance Against Commissions for Sally

DateAccount TitleDebit ($)Credit ($)NotesEarnings DateCommission Expense3,000To record the commission earned by SallyEarnings DateCommission Payable or Cash3,000To record the obligation to pay Sally her earned commissionEarnings DateAdvance Against Commissions2,000To reduce the advance against commissions liability as Sally earns it backEarnings DateCommission Payable or Cash2,000To clear the obligation against the advance Sally had received

Example 2 - Recoverable Draws

Imagine you provide Mark with a $1,500 "recoverable draw" against future commissions. If Mark earns $2,000 in commissions for the month, you'd pay him the remaining $500 ($2,000 earned minus $1,500 draw), and the draw account returns to zero.

DateAccount TitleDebit ($)Credit ($)NotesDraw DateRecoverable Draw1,500To record the recoverable draw provided to MarkDraw DateCash or Bank1,500To record the payment of recoverable draw to MarkEarnings DateCommission Expense2,000To record Mark's earned commissionsEarnings DateRecoverable Draw1,500To reduce the draw account as Mark has earned commissionsEarnings DateCash or Bank500To record the net commission payment to Mark

Both advances and recoverable draws are mechanisms to provide some financial stability to salespeople. However, they carry different financial and tax implications, both for the individual and the company. It's crucial to understand these differences and account for them correctly.

Reconciliation Process

Regularly reconcile commission accounts to avoid discrepancies. Think of reconciliation as a financial double-check. You're basically making sure that what you think you owe in commissions (or have already paid out) matches up with your sales records and bank statements.

Example: At the end of the month, you take a look at what your accounting software says you've paid in commissions and compare it to your bank account. If everything lines up, great! If not, you'll need to figure out why and fix it.

Note: Failure to accurately record sales commissions can result in not just financial errors but also legal issues or audits from tax authorities like the IRS. Therefore, meticulous record-keeping is crucial.

4. Tax Implications of Sales Commissions

When it comes to sales commissions, tax authorities have their guidelines that both employers and employees need to follow. Here's a simplified rundown to help you navigate the tax maze:

For Employees

Commissions, just like regular salaries, are subject to taxes, and you'll need to account for this in your payroll. These deductions will cover various tax obligations, depending on your jurisdiction.

Quick Tip: When year-end rolls around, make sure your accounting is spot-on. Your financial statements should reflect not only salaries but also the total commissions paid out and the taxes withheld. This ensures smooth sailing when tax season arrives.

For Employers

As the business owner, you're responsible for withholding the right amount of taxes from your employees' commission payments. Plus, don't forget about your share of taxes like FICA (Social Security and Medicare).

Heads Up: Keep an eye on tax filing deadlines, both quarterly and annually. Missing them could result in penalties.

Business Deductions

Good news! In most cases, the commissions you pay out can be deducted from your taxable income, which could lower your tax bill. The tax code has specific rules about what can be deducted, so it's smart to consult a tax advisor to make sure you're on the right track.

Note: Given the complexity of tax regulations, consulting a tax professional for personalized advice is highly recommended.

5. Legal Considerations

When it comes to commissions, don't rely on a handshake or verbal agreement. Make sure all your commission plans are buttoned up with legal contracts. This not only protects you but also sets clear expectations for your team.

Take Note: Laws can vary depending on where your business is based. Always check to make sure your commission agreements comply with your local, regional, or national laws to avoid any legal hiccups down the line.

6. Best Practices

Looking to fine-tune your sales commission strategy? Here are some no-nonsense tips to keep your sales team motivated and your accounting straightforward.

• Set Clear GoalsStart with achievable targets that align with your business aims. Make sure everyone knows what they're shooting for; it removes guesswork.
• Pick Your Model WiselyDifferent businesses, different needs. Pick a commission model that suits your sales cycle and team dynamics. It could be a game-changer.
• Keep It TransparentEveryone on the team should know the rules of the game. Share the commission rates and structures openly; no one likes hidden surprises.
• Pay On TimeTimely commission payments keep the spirits high. It's a simple way to tell your team that you value their effort.
• Stay AgileIs the current model working for everyone? Keep an eye on the metrics and be ready to tweak things if necessary.
• Check the Books RegularlyRegularly matching your recorded commissions with actual payments helps avoid nasty surprises at the end of the fiscal year.
• Use the Right ToolsA good accounting software can be your best friend, keeping track of the numbers so you can focus on strategy.
• Stay on the Right Side of the LawDraft clear commission agreements and run them by a legal advisor. You don’t want to be caught off guard by legal issues.
• Reward the StarsGot team members who are crushing it? Reward them with bonuses or better commission rates. It sets the bar high for everyone else.
• Do an Annual Check-upTake time at the end of the year to review how your commission structure has performed. It's your blueprint for the next year.

Conclusion

Absolutely, getting your commission structures right is a win-win scenario. It helps motivate your sales team, fueling them to bring their A-game, while also aligning with your business objectives for sustainable growth.

Use the insights from this guide as a roadmap to navigate the complexities of sales commissions, from choosing the right model and types to accounting and tax implications. The time invested in optimizing these structures can yield high returns in employee satisfaction and bottom-line results.

‍